...
| Comment # | Document (Policy / MRPS) | Document line / reference | Proposed Change or Query | Proposer / Affiliation | Reply Candidate |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| #1 | Policy | Section 4&5 | In Section 5 says that all membership applications will be evaluated by the Federation Operator. If this is the case I am not sure if the distinction between accredited R&E institutions (as described in Section 4) and other IdPs/attribute authorities/SPs is necessary. | Casper Dreef / eduGAIN secretariat | Regarding the 1st comment relative to Accredited R&E institutions, this point was made because some institutions might not be accredited by the government R&E regulation authority. But, we can not find other IdPs/attribute authorities/SPs in Section 4&5 in the policy document. |
| #2 | Policy | Appendix | This is a copy of the eduID.ng policy. Nigeria is mentioned where it should be Burkina Faso. | Casper Dreef / eduGAIN secretariat | Solved |
| #3 | Policy/MRPS | general | Please make sure the font is consistent throughout the document. | Casper Dreef / eduGAIN secretariat | Solved |
| #4 | Policy | Section 6 Jurisdiction | In the second paragraph, please refer to a specific court of law. | Casper Dreef / eduGAIN secretariat | Solved |
| #5 | MRPS | Section 3 | Second paragraph. This is URL linking to the current version of the document. When the policy gets updated, the url changes. This then must be reflected in the MRPS as well. It would be easier to link to a general webpage with an url that is less like to be changed | Casper Dreef / eduGAIN secretariat | Still links directly to the policy document, but this is now the updated version. |
| #6 | MRPS | Section 3 | Paragraph 5. Remove () around Insitutionsou munistè ESR etc. | Casper Dreef / eduGAIN secretariat | Solved |
| #7 | MRPS | Section 6.1 | provide email address / registry tool / other tools | Casper Dreef / eduGAIN secretariat | Solved |
| #8 | Metadata | Please provide the metadata URL for the signed metadata. The current link only shows unsigned MD. |